?>
Who's still around?
GTX0 NewestRepliesHottestMy Active
NIFE UpdatesRoadmapRequests | HelpDiscuss Game Worlds


Any Persona fans?
Posted: Posted June 10th by tnu
View Source Report Thread Views

I'm getting back in to it. and I've wanted folks to talk sh opw ith.

Sir, just suppose... suppose if I had a cat, what would you do with Frankenstein?
There are 13 Replies
Load all posts On page: 1 2
  settingsSettings

Persona 3, 4, and 5 are some of the best games I have ever played. What is your favorite of the three?

Posted June 12th by Laxan
View Source Quote Report
Laxan
 

I've played most of 4 (Up to ) and all of Persona 5 sand it's a tough call. I have some biases that lean me towards 5 due to its motifs, UI, the return of the negotiation system and

Posted June 12th by tnu
View Source Quote Report
tnu

I like the story of 3 and 4 better than 5, and the music of Persona 3 and 4 are better than 5 to me. But, the art style and gameplay is strongest in 5 (although, I feel a few dungeons towards the latter half of P5 are too damn long).

Since 5 falls short in story and music while 3 and 4 still have a great art style and solid gameplay, I'd have to say 5 is my least favorite.

I was more into Makoto myself.

Posted June 12th by Laxan
View Source Quote Report
Laxan
 

I'm a fan of Phantom Thieeves as an archatype personally so there's alot of bias there the dunegeons in 4 were oftne less stressful and mroe fun to grind Actualy doing a new run because I lost my saves. tyring anew approach where I prioritize socia links based on what Personas I have in my stock. I don't now much about the sotry of 3 be yond people turning in to Coffins admittedly and in regards to P4 and while I like Makoto I feel like she's overrated.

Posted June 12th by tnu
View Source Quote Report
tnu

As soon as I saw Makoto, I knew she was going to be the one I made the MC date, and she ended up being as awesome as I had hoped.

When I played Persona 3, I loved it so much it almost became my new favourite game.

I knew I had to try Persona 4 next, and I figured I would like it but I had a hard time imaging myself liking it more than Persona 3. I ended up liking it more than Persona 3, and it too almost became my new favourite game.

When Persona 5 was announced, I said to myself, "Ok, this is more Persona so you know it's gonna be awesome, but don't get your hopes up too much because there's no way it will outdo Persona 4". Persona 5 is my favourite game now. XD I loved it so much that I played it twice in a row.

I've since done my second playthroughs of Persona 3 and 4. Having experienced Persona 5, it was interesting going back and making comparisons. I'd be curious to see how you guys compare the three games. Honestly, I could ramble on for hours comparing and analyzing the stories, main characters, supporting characters, dungeons, battle mechanics, social links, etc etc etc etc etc (but I wouldn't torment you like that).

Edited June 13th by Jo Nathan
View Source Quote Report

I wi sh I had a decent wya to access Persona 3. My Playstation TV was repalced by SOny and I ha eabackup I ordered on Ebay so i'm good for playing 4 but 3 is really hard to get access to. is also legit most relatable of the party. and a personal hot take. I like Ohya a lot.


As for comparisons I thin before playing 5 you should play at least one of the others so the reveal has the proper impact and because Naoto and Yukiko are great!

Edited June 14th by tnu
View Source Quote Report
tnu

I agree, playing at least one of the others before 5 would be ideal for that reason alone, but there are other reasons on top of that. For example-



literally made me burst out laughing when I saw that for the first time.

Posted June 14th by Jo Nathan
View Source Quote Report

literally made me burst out laughing when I saw that for the first time.



Can't disagree with that.

Edited June 14th by tnu
View Source Quote Report
tnu

I find the philosophy and themes of Persona 3 and 4 much more focused when compared to the themes and philosophy of Persona 5. I felt as though they got to the end of development and on that final level, Persona Team had a brain fart and suddenly remembered that they were supposed to be implementing the themes of P5 into the overall narrative, hence why the theme of "people desiring to be imprisoned in their own self woe"--which is a cool idea and totally Persona-esque--kind of comes out of nowhere in the final stretch of P5. Whereas P3's themes (life and death and how people come to terms with how they want to live their lives) and P4's themes (seeking out the truth for yourself, questioning everything around you) are very focused and consistent all throughout.

I didn't feel like there really WAS a strong, cohesive theme in P5, and that is a major flaw in storytelling. Sure, there is the Phantom Thieves motif (which is cool as hell, don't get me wrong), but like...what is the game really trying to say? Change people's hearts and minds with...magic? What kind of lame-ass theme is that? To clarify, I REALLY despised that EVERY Social Link/Confidant was developed only after you used your Persona powers on that social link's/confidant's heart. As in, you only changed these people's lives because you used magic to change their hearts.

In Persona 3 and 4, you changed people's lives because you spent time with them during their social links and important key moments in their lives. They learned from you and grew with you--they didn't need Persona powers to impact their lives like the Confidants did in P5... You did it all on your own just by being a good human being to the people who mattered in your fictional Persona 3 and 4 lives.

And that is a major part of why I feel the storytelling in Persona 5 is weaker than previous entries. If we want to talk about the main story, I have to call out the theme again. I feel the theme of the game was supposed to be about what the last level goes over....but I didn't feel that anywhere else in the rest of the game. Maybe vaguely, but not strong enough. And the main characters are...decent. Nowhere near as strong as P3 and P4. (Especially P3 where each character continued to develop throughout the entire game and their development didn't stop just because you completed a dungeon that was related to them...looking at you, P4 and P5.)

Also, when you finally confront Goro Akechi inside Shido's heart, it gets a bit too over-the-top and ridiculous. Akechi's mannerisms and "crazy, wild eyes" are just too unbelievable of a reaction and sudden personality pivot for that character. I could also see the twist coming from a mile away that he was going to betray you (pancakes, anyone?). It was a weak showdown with what should have a been a great sendoff to a well-developed character. How can a game be so long and have so many cutscenes yet fail to capture proper development of characters? It irked me pretty hard.

My theory, as I've stated, is that Persona Team focused more on developing gameplay and art style for P5, because I will not argue that gameplay and art style is indeed strongest in P5. They just focused TOO much on the art and gameplay to the point that it became a detriment to the story, characters, and even the music. (Come on, Shoji Meguro. You can do better than that...)

That's just my opinion. Sorry for the long rant. I love this series and P5 is still an awesome game! Just not as good as P3 or P4.

Posted June 16th by Laxan
View Source Quote Report
Laxan
 

Gameplay and worldbuilding are def more important to me than superficial stuff like messages and themes. build your characters as people and your setting as a place rather than a means to deliver themes and messages and you can't go wrong IMO.


In my opinion reflection and "holding a mirror to society" or what have you is NOT depth. amirror has no depth or identity of its own. it's a blank slate that can only mimic what it sees and try to claim that depth.

Edited June 16th by tnu
View Source Quote Report
tnu
Next page Load rest of pages On page: /
Reply to: Any Persona fans?
Enter your message here

Site Rules | Complaints Process | Give Feedback Facebook Page
GTX0 © 2009-2019 Xhin GameTalk © 1999-2008 lives on
You are not forgotten, Kevin, Liane, Norma, Jason, and Garrett